21 August 2012

What makes a great teacher?

Filed in Leadership Issues, Teaching and Learning

Over the last 25 years I’ve worked with hundreds of different teachers and had the privilege of watching hundreds of lessons in the schools I’ve worked in and supported. My children have had a quite a few teachers now and I have their perspective too….

What makes a great teacher?

Over the last 25 years I’ve worked with hundreds of different teachers and had the privilege of watching hundreds of lessons in the schools I’ve worked in and supported. My children have had a quite a few teachers now and I have their perspective too. Without doubt, it is fair to say that there is a range but right at the top of the pile, some teachers are simply exceptional. These are the teachers everyone raves about; you’d love them to teach your children; they inspire, enthuse, make learning accessible and challenging and get great results as well. At KEGS, they become ‘legends’. For me, they are the profession’s superstars; the people I look up to and strive to emulate.

I may never be an exceptional teacher – but I’d like to be better! So, as the new term approaches, I’ve been thinking about the very best teachers I’ve known. At first, they are all seem so idiosyncratic in their approach; uniquely charismatic and impossible to copy. But, if we are aspiring to join them, is there anything that they have in common that we can learn from and put into practice in our own lessons?

Well, actually, yes. I’m sure there is proper academic research in this area, but based purely on my subjective evaluations, here is my list:

1) They are drivers: Almost above all else, I’d say this is the key characteristic. They are standards-setters, never happy with mediocre work or sloppy thinking; always pushing every child to go further, to aim higher. This manifests itself through classroom dialogue, the inherent challenge in lessons, routinely giving challenging and engaging homework and so on. They are relentless in pursuit of excellence and their language with students is infused with this sense of urgency and drive: come on, there is another level; you can do it. Some have a glass half-empty demeanour; for some the glass is always nearly full….but the effect is the same.

2) They nurture student-teacher relationships based on genuine mutual respect, where there is no argument about expected standards of behaviour. They achieve this in different ways – sometimes through the gravitas of maturity and experience; sometimes through amazing warm, interpersonal interactions with every child – but they create an environment where learning always thrives and there is a sense of the teacher and their students enjoying each other’s company. Their rapport with students is palpably warm, friendly and trusting.

3) They take joy in going off piste.. using deep subject expertise to go beyond the syllabus, inspiring students with their passion and their capacity to make connections and to tell stories or give examples that bring it all alive. At the same time, they take exams really seriously…. It is not one or the other. Exams are not the be all and end all – they include all the ‘fun stuff’ as well – but if you want an A*, you’d be in safe hands.

4) They celebrate the intrinsic reward and motivating power of learning and achieving and use this to great effect. To varying degrees, they have the ability to explain complex concepts in ways that make sense; they ask good questions and give really good feedback; they are usually experts in the use of AfL (even if they don’t always call it that); however it is done, students feel that they are learning; they know where they stand and feel confident about the process. This is reward and motivation enough.

5) They are principled about people, about learning and work with integrity. This means that they do things for the right reasons – usually self-effacing and not the ‘big ego’ type. They are learners, happy to explore new ideas to develop their practice, but always in a way that captures the spirit; ie they are not slaves to the tick box or the OfSTED crib sheet; they embrace change with integrity, with passion – or not at all.

It is obviously hard to capture – and some of the idiosyncrasy gets lost in the generalisation. But if we adopt the right attitudes and embrace the challenge, I don’t think it is unrealistic to meet these standards. The hard part is to manage them all. Crucially, even the greatest teachers are not at their optimum day in, day out…. but their routine core practice is so strong that they never fall too far from their peak.


See also:  Creating the conditions for great teachers to thrive

The Great Lessons Series

1. Probing  2. Rigour  3.Challenge  4. Differentiation 5. Journeys 6. Explaining  7. Agility 8. Awe 9.Possibilities 10. Joy

No Comments
  • Nina
    Posted at 15:50h, 24 August

    Excellent choices! Too seldom I hear teachers even talk about intrinsic motivation – yet that is such an important part in learning. Somehow balancing the requirements of education as an institutionalized force (transferring the culture to the next generation) and the joy of exploring new ideas (preparing students for the big unknown, i.e. future) creates the greatness in teaching. How could we help more teachers achieve that in their daily practice?

    Thank you for this wonderful post!

  • Christopher Waugh
    Posted at 11:51h, 30 August

    I find this post deeply affirming. Thank you for putting into words the things that make me so proud to be an exponent of the teaching profession. Let’s hope we can get some of this kind of talk onto the national education agenda this year!

  • Andy Day
    Posted at 09:42h, 31 August

    How often do we hear “If only you could put it in a bottle and market it….” Think at least you’ve gone as far as listing the ingredients on the label. Sharp and perceptive distillation of essentials. Says a lot about the perspicacity of the observer/headguruteacher.

  • Creating the conditions for great teachers to thrive « headguruteacher
    Posted at 23:27h, 22 September

    […] previous post, What makes a great teacher?, has had the most hits (just ahead of the one about marking!)  I suppose that’s not […]

  • “The Edutronic”: A great teacher flourishing « headguruteacher
    Posted at 21:28h, 06 October

    […] Nautical School to meet Mr Edutronic, Christopher Waugh.  Chris contacted me after I wrote about ‘What makes a great teacher’ and I then took a look at what he has been doing at his school with the Edutronic_Net website. […]

  • Habib Abdul Aziz
    Posted at 04:52h, 10 February

    good awareness,please,thank you!

  • Outstanding teaching and great teachers – a whole school CPD approach | Teaching: Leading Learning
    Posted at 22:58h, 02 March

    […] time his post on becoming a “truly great school”, and by Tom Sherrington’s post “what makes a great teacher”, we ditched the “outstanding” tag and replaced it with […]

  • Blogs round-up 2nd Sept | Weekly Maths
    Posted at 17:05h, 11 March

    […] What makes a great teacher? […]

  • A Year in the Life of Headguruteacher | headguruteacher
    Posted at 08:05h, 10 May

    […] the summer, @Edutronic_net:  Chris Waugh left a comment on my post ‘What makes a great teacher‘? Ever since we’ve been in communication, met a few times and shared some great […]

  • What makes great teaching? | Pragmatic Education
    Posted at 10:40h, 11 May

    […] ‘What makes a great teacher? was a popular post. I suppose that’s not surprising; people are intrigued to know what the answer might be. Am I a great teacher? Can I be a great teacher? What would it take for me to feel that this applies to me? We all want to know. I’m the same’.  […]

  • Outstanding teaching and great teachers – part 2 | Teaching: Leading Learning
    Posted at 20:44h, 10 July

    […] “How we will become a truly great school” and Tom Sherrington’s “what makes a great teacher?” Again, you can read what our teachers though in our booklet: Great Teachers. Whilst there […]

  • How might social media help teachers improve education? | Pragmatic Education
    Posted at 12:27h, 13 July

    […] What makes a great teacher? – Tom Sherrington […]

  • Part 1(of 2) Great Learning: 3 qualities that separate the best from the rest.. | From the Sandpit....
    Posted at 17:54h, 31 July

    […] Read also ‘What makes a Great Teacher’ by Tom Sherrington […]

  • What makes a great teacher? | huntingenglish
    Posted at 19:11h, 31 July

    […] This blog post is directly inspired by reading a blog post by @headguruteacher on ‘creating the conditions for great teachers to thrive’, which links back to the post which has given rise to my attempt: http://headguruteacher.com/2012/08/21/what-makes-a-great-teacher/ […]

  • The visual anatomy of a #GreatTeacher? by @TeacherToolkit | @ TeacherToolkit
    Posted at 18:12h, 10 January

    […] If the handcuffs of education were removed, how would the good teacher evolve into greatness? Would lines of good and great still remain blurred? Would they flourish into innovation? Perhaps offer alternatives for us all? Truly promote a love of learning without the restrictions of examination dogma? Perhaps a great teacher may become too abstract and lose sight of greatness? Sherrington provides his analysis here. […]

  • Scale: CPD, research, and getting the basics right. | headguruteacher
    Posted at 13:55h, 15 May

    […] one of my early blog posts, I wrote about Great Teachers. It was based on a lengthy mental scan of the many excellent teachers I’ve known. I could […]

  • Patricia Kokkinou
    Posted at 11:47h, 26 July

    Reblogged this on Geography is easy! and commented:
    From a great blog on education!

  • Features of effective teaching | TeachGeog
    Posted at 11:34h, 07 September

    […] If you want to know  more about the characteristics of Effective Teachers: Read this page from Stanford University: Characteristics of effective teachers. Read this article from headguruteacher. […]

  • 10 Teaching Essentials | headguruteacher
    Posted at 10:51h, 26 October

    […] they might have in common.  (Something I’ve done many times before e.g. in this early post: What makes a great teacher?). Secondly, I’ve been thinking about how to support early career teachers to improve and to […]